Small Market Roundtable: Media Coverage
This is the 4th installment of the SB Nation football small market roundtable. Today's topic is media coverage. We are going to look at it from two different aspects: 1. The lack of media coverage that small market teams get from the national media, and 2. The way the local media covers the team.
National Media Coverage
If you have watched ESPN in this off-season you can only leave with one conclusion, the New England Patriots are going to win the Super Bowl. What is the point in even playing the 2007 season? Check out this screen shot that Brad over at Stampede Blue captured last week from ESPN.com. That's right, 3 NFL "spotlight" stories and all 3 are about the Patriots. Tom Brady is seen walking around in a Yankees hat and it is earth shattering news, meanwhile, you haven't heard a word from ESPN about the Titans moving their first round pick from safety to corner. If you don't live in Tennessee you probably haven't heard anything about that.
The lack of national media coverage can also hurt the players that play in a small market. The guys that are on SportsCenter every time you turn around are going to be the guys that get the big endorsement contracts. I do understand that the huge stars are going to get the deals wherever they go, but it is the really good players that aren't quite stars that are hurt. Take a guy like Keith Bulluck. He is a great player but you don't see him on any commercials.
The other disadvantage to players comes in Pro Bowl voting. Most fans aren't digging through the stats to determine who gets their Pro Bowl vote. They are going to vote for the guys they see on SportsCenter every Sunday night. I could go through all of the injustices to Titans players over the years, but I will spare everyone from my whining. I do have to highlight one though. In 2005 Kyle Vanden Bosch was 2nd in the AFC with 12.5 sacks, yet he was not elected to the Pro Bowl. It took an injury to get him there.
My favorite national media bias comes from the guru that is Merrill Hoge. If you have ever seen Hoge on his NFL Match Up show, you probably know how he feels about Vince Young. Here is a little video that will bring you up to speed on Hoge's feelings. Yes, I realize I am being a HUGE homer here, but if Vince was playing for the Patriots, Giants, or Jets ESPN would have forced Hoge to change his tune. (Now we can have fun watching Peter and Brad debate Vince's QB abilities in the comments.)
Local Media Coverage
I can't speak for all small market media, so I am going to approach this strictly from a Tennessee perspective. The media in Tennessee is not nearly as hard on the team as, say, the New York media would be on the Giants or Jets. When things are going bad here, most writers and talk show hosts still search hard for that silver lining. The only writers who don't are the ones who originally worked in a big media market. The fans are the same way. If someone calls in to a radio show when the team is 0-5 and rips them, the next 6 callers will talk about how that person needs to be a true fan nad support the team no matter what. Overall coverage is a lot more positive here than it would be in most markets.
It is also easier for teams to conceal things in a small market. If you remember last season, Vince Young's first start was the immortal head stomp game in week 4 against the Cowboys. Vince took all of the snaps with the first team that week in practices that writers attended. Jeff Fisher had basically told the local media if it was leaked that practices would be closed for the rest of the season. The story was not broken until Saturday night. There is absolutely no way that would have been kept under raps in New York or Chicago.
In conclusion, being a small market has its advantages and disadvantages when it comes to media coverage. The disadvantages are the lack of exposure given to the team and the players on programs such as SportsCenter. This hurts the players from a recognition standpoint, which keeps them from getting endorsement contracts and Pro Bowl votes.
The advantage is the team has an easier time keeping information from getting out. In most cases that would help give the team an upper hand because their opponent wouldn't know what to gameplan for. Of course in the case of the Titans and Cowboys, all it lead to was a 31 point loss, one of the worst on field incidents in sports history, and some CB saying his team needs more thugs. I bet you can't guess how that was.
Update [2007-6-13 11:25:3 by Jimmy]:The Bulluck vs. Lewis tackles stat has been removed because it was wrong. Thanks for the head's up Will. I am a moron.
0 recs |
19
comments
Comments
Double check the math:
I count Ray Lewis as having 811 tackles since 2000, and he did that in fewer games than Keith Bullock as well, given that Lewis only started 5 and 6 games in 2002 and 2005 respectively.
In my opinion, Ray Lewis gets endorsement deals over Bullock because he's been a better player.
by Skin Patrol on Jun 13, 2007 10:19 AM CDT 0 recs
You are correct
by Jimmy on Jun 13, 2007 10:23 AM CDT 0 recs
No problem
by Skin Patrol on
Jun 13, 2007 10:26 AM CDT
up
0 recs
Great post
by Skin Patrol on Jun 13, 2007 10:30 AM CDT 0 recs
Someone had to say it
by ElectricScissors on Jun 13, 2007 12:19 PM CDT 0 recs
Good read, Jimmy
I'll say this - being from Western New York, I've heard pretty much two Titans themes up here throughout the entire off-season. I'm betting that 95% of Titans fans know what they are, so say it with me, folks:
"Pac-Man Jones and the 'terrible' off-season."
For what it's worth, other small markets don't really like what your team has done either.
by Brian G on Jun 13, 2007 12:40 PM CDT 0 recs
What do you mean
by Jimmy on
Jun 13, 2007 12:59 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Allow me to specify
I apologize for not being clear - I meant specifically that the Buffalo market isn't to keen on what your team has done this off-season. It was just sort of a conclusion-type sentence, it wasn't meant to speak for the rest of the small markets out there.
Also for what it's worth, I was high on Griffin going into the draft and think you got a heck of a football player. Screw popular opinion, your draft was pretty good.
by Brian G on
Jun 13, 2007 2:46 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Now I understand
by Jimmy on
Jun 13, 2007 2:57 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Direct line to other small market?
by TrenchantTitan on
Jun 13, 2007 1:06 PM CDT
up
0 recs
The same way Jimmy can speak for this market
by Skin Patrol on
Jun 13, 2007 3:46 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Pro Bowl Schmo Bowl
That being said, not a one of them came even close to being sent to the Pro Bowl.
But Tony Romo did.
Nuff Said.
-Chris
(Great Post Jimmy!)
by River City Rage on Jun 13, 2007 2:34 PM CDT 0 recs
O-Linemen
But to defend the Pro Bowl voters, the offensive line has two jobs, and only one of them involves running the ball. The Jage line gave up a sack 6.2% of passing plays which, incidentally, was the NFL average. Good for 18th in the league.
by Skin Patrol on
Jun 13, 2007 3:49 PM CDT
up
0 recs
FYI
by BigBlueShoe on Jun 13, 2007 3:47 PM CDT 0 recs
Let Me Tell You A Little Story
The "Love Boat" thing was 2 years ago? There are still jokes about it on a regular basis. Not even the Ohio State Penal League All-Stars. . .er, Cincinnati Bengals. . .take as much crap for their transgressions as the Vikings have for one incident. Never mind the fact that 3/4 of the people that actually faced charges for that whole thing are no longer with the team.
The thing with the Vikings "missing" their pick at the draft happened five drafts ago? Funny. . .the first thing that ESPN did when the Vikings' first-round pick came up this year was show the video of it happening. (To their credit, the NFL Network didn't even mention said incident. Just another part of the NFL Network's coverage completely kicking ESPN's ass.)
Another funny aside from that. . .nobody at ESPN ever seems to mention the fact that the Vikings "settled" for a guy that's now one of the 5 best players in the league at his position, while the Ravens (who screwed the Vikings over on a trade they had set up at that point) wound up giving up their first round pick in the next draft so they could move up and draft Kyle friggin' Boller. Yes, folks. . .Brian Billick, offensive genius.
Now that my standard ESPN hatred is out of the way. . .
Jimmy's hit the nail right on the head. The Vikings just let Jermaine Wiggins go after 3 years in Minnesota. Did you know that over the past 3 years, the only two tight ends in the entire National Football League that had more receptions than Jermaine Wiggins' total of 186 were a couple of schmucks named Tony Gonzalez and Antonio Gates? And no TE in the NFC had more catches. But did Wiggy get anywhere near a Pro Bowl? Nope. He got to watch while Jeremy Shockey (one of the kings of overrated-ness) went to Hawai'i every year instead. Switch Wiggins and Shockey, and I think a lot of people would be asking "Jeremy who?"
I'm too far removed from Minneapolis-St. Paul to talk about the local TV and radio media, but the Vikings' beat writers for the St. Paul Pioneer Press and the Minneapolis Star-Tribune are notoriously negative, all the damn time. I've ripped quite a few of them on my site for their constant bile. If these guys aren't bitching, they aren't happy. I know each market has their negative writers, but the MSP media takes it to an extreme.
by GonzoDN on Jun 13, 2007 8:46 PM CDT 0 recs
Dude.
The only year Wiggins could legitimately call for a Pro Bowl was 2004, and he got beat out (rightfully) by Cooley and Crumpler.
Wiggins hasn't even led the NFC TEs in receptions once -- in 2004 Witten had 87 to Wiggins 71, in 2005 Chris Cooley had 71 to Wiggins 69, and in 2006 Wiggins only had 46 receptions (fewer than Cooley, Shockey, and Witten). That's just the NFC East, I don't know where Alge Crumpler weighs against him.
Not to mention Wiggins has 6 touchdowns in that entire stretch, and probably the worst YPC in the entire NFL.
by Skin Patrol on
Jun 14, 2007 8:49 AM CDT
up
0 recs
Correction:
by Skin Patrol on
Jun 14, 2007 8:50 AM CDT
up
0 recs
I wouldn't
Now I live in North Dakota and live 6 hours from the Twin Cities and guess what? I hear TON's on the vikings. Actually that is all I hear.
Me and My neighbor were just talking about this this morning. The Vikings Market isn't just Minn. It's North Dakota, South Dakota, Iowa, Southern Manatoba (Canada).
Teams Like the Titans, Bills, Jag's are truely the small Market teams.
I'd also like to mention that most stories reported in other markets, Such as in the Bills market come from the AP releases. So when the article about how bad the Titans off-season has gone it was an AP release that was just re-printed into the local media.
by white02slpss on
Jun 20, 2007 8:57 AM CDT
up
0 recs
good thoughts, jimmy
ps - i didn't think it could happen, but the Pats are getting even more coverage than in the past.....how is this possible? This kind of over the top reporting on the Pats by ESPN and SI just further the hatred the rest of the league has against the Pats....
by zackmann on Jun 14, 2007 9:27 AM CDT 0 recs










