This is a two horse race. Kevin Dyson MUST be in the conversation. "But Jimmy, he was the one who scored on the Music City Miracle- the play that you named your site after." I understand that, but he did a whole lot of nothing for this team outside of that, and if we are being honest, he didn't do a lot on that play. As I have said before, Gramsey could have scored behind that wall (TWSS).
Also, he was the only receiver picked ahead of Randy Moss.
The second option here is Andre Woolfolk. He is probably actually the winner. He was a first round pick who played more like a guy that should have been an undrafted free agent....in the CFL.
You can also throw Chris Henry into the mix, but he was a second round pick where both of the guys mentioned above were first round picks.
Who is your worst draft pick ever?