For Gramsey
I'm gonna do my best to explain why (I think) I feel the way that I do. I even asked for help with this yesterday when I couldn't figure out what was going on in my head in the (pull up a chair gentleman) fanpost. Where to start, I guess I should start by saying we will never know the truth about anything, so we always have to read into everything. It was like the steroids in baseball thing 5-10 years ago. Try and figured everything out for yourself and do your best to read between the lines with everything Vince or Fisher has to say. Its really easy to do with Vince cuz in all reality he's kinda dopey. Much harder to do with Fisher cuz he can be kinda sneaky which is actually something I always liked about him. So pretty much everything that I feel I pretty much made up for myself lol.
I wouldn't say Fisher had it out for Vince from day 1, but I don't feel he ever wanted him which is pretty common knowledge. It started when Bud decided to draft him. There was an instance in a game a few years ago where VY kinda challenged Fisherball, I believe it was against Jax. Vince took it upon himself to audible to a pass on a 3rd down while we were running out the clock. I really think Fisher wanted to be done with him then. I don't think he liked being questioned. In that case Fisher was in the right, but it was a way bigger deal and stuck if Fisher's mind more than people think.
I really feel Vince quit on the team as everyone else did 2 years ago verse Jax. While I wanted nothing to do with him for a time, I forgave him as a fan for that. Everyone obviously deserves a 2nd chance. I don't think Fisher on the other hand ever did, nor did I think he had any plans to have him as his starter ever again.
Fisher was forced by ineffective play by Collins, the lack of another option last year and Bud to put VY back out on the field at 0-6. I'm sure Vince knows this and feels the same way. After last the last 10 games of last season and the start that Vince got off to he was starting to feel it was his team. He was the leader, and he could take this team where it needed to go.
The game against the Steelers I would say we all would agree we were pretty surprised to see VY get benched. It was probably pretty shocking for him as well, and I think at that point VY was hurt and didn't really show it. I think at that point VY had given up on Fisher whether he was named starter the following week or not, VY's confidence was shot and the leadership role took a serious hit. Whether the intent was there or not Fisher pretty much said to VInce and the rest of the team "Fuck you" this is my team.
Vince was healthy enough to start against Miami. Fisher saw an opportunity to start Kerry and took advantage of it. Like I said this is just how I see it. Vince wanted to start and Fisher probably said something along the lines of "I don't wanna see you hurt yourself further to jeopardize our season" all the while hoping Kerry went out there to tear it up to give him a reason to hand Kerry the job. The media starts to question Vince's toughness which just keeps fueling the fire in Vince's head.
Through all this time while Dinger drew em up Fisher made the decisions on how they approached the playcalling. You couldn't help but notice that when Collins was in we always made a point to throw the ball downfield, it really stood out in the Philly game. There were numerous times when we as fans said "please let this guy throw the ball more", even this year. You don't think this had a effect on Vince's mindset and how they felt about him? Furthermore adding more fuel to Vince's fire.
Now don't get me wrong, you all know I love and respected Fisher just as much as the next guy, but why is everyone acting like we just started questioning him and some of his decisions? Like some of us hate him for what happened with Vince. Like we have to take a side in this right now. We have been question Fisher since 0-3 last year. The decisions to make Ryan Mouton a returner, to cut all other return options. The decision to constantly send Nick Harper out there to get torched week after week. The constant personal fouls, the constant penalties all over the place whether its an encroachment or a hold. If Eugene Amano can't make a block without getting a holding penalty, fuckin find someone who will. If the DTs and DEs can't get penetration without getting 15 encroachment penalties a game, fuckin find someone who will. Now I'm not blaming the fact that this team doesn't have a Super Bowl in his time here squarely on his shoulders. Just saying we haven't always been on his or a side. And for the life of me I cannot understand why every time someone questions a Fisher decision the wanna be Fisher apologist have to jump out and say "Here we go, lets fire Fisher for this too" sarcastically. You can question a coach without wanting him fired. Fisher is adored throughout the country for being a guy that players like to play for cuz he takes it easy on em throughout the otas, doesn't kill em in practices and camps, he's well spoken, obviously smart, he's good looking, so he's a pretty well rounded guy. He's not known as a winner, and that's what matters to me
Where I'm at with Fisher, and some of you have said some of the same. He's become very prideful, his ego has gotten in the way more than once over the last couple of years I don't know what he's trying to prove, but I've seen enough of the Elvis sunglasses and the finely tuned beards. I wanna see this team legally punch other teams in the mouth, this guy let the beard grow how it wants, take off the shades and pretty shirts and find ways to make this team work on a consistent basis. No more 8-8s. While I know VY can be a bit of a child at times, can anyone on here say Fisher has done the best he can with Vince? I would say if anything he has actually brought out the worst in him.
On to the VY situation and why this is different for me than the usual "I'm going to dismiss him, nor do I care for him anymore at all" routine I go through with some clown ass players. I actually feel for the guy, Lord only knows why... He's been handed everything on a Silver platter and he still finds ways to Fuck it up. I feel that he learned a lot from his mistake a couple years ago against Jax, I feel that he worked hard to get better, I feel he worked hard to become a leader, yet he still makes those mistakes as a person that make you shake your head. As a player I really think he's turned the corner, and I do not wanna start fresh and wait for the next guy to progress. I'm 33, I take being a fan serious. Every single year I say a team is gonna win the Super Bowl, by the time I'm dead odds are mine has to be one of them. This will prolong that experience in my opinion. Some of you I know feel Vince doesn't have what it takes mentally to do this. I think in the right situation with the right support he can. Yeah sure he's more fragile mentally than a lot of other QBs for whatever reason, but really who doesn't want to be loved? I still play sports competitively, I play in a full contact flag league with some pretty good athletes. I also play open modified/sling softball leagues. I run some of the teams, there's guys on team anywhere from 1-15 years younger than I am... Some good, some bad but I see how they are. I see the big difference on my son's teams from how shit was when we played. The athletes are a bit more babyish and high maintenance than they used to be. I'm the guy that runs hard when I ground out, jogs back to the dugout and puts his helmet down, gets ready to play some more... I'm the guy on the football field that plays as hard as I can every single play and rarely shows emotion. But I see the kid in that younger age group fly out, start cursing, throw their helmets, text in the dugout the whole ordeal... I see the guys on the football field that can't keep their mouths shut no matter what they do good or bad. I look at Vince and I see a younger guy that has this mostly under control... I can forgive and root for him cuz I really think he's a good guy. I don't see the T.O. crap in him, he doesn't call out teammates, he doesn't cry when they don't let him throw the ball. He threw a fit cuz he wanted to go back in the game and the coach wouldn't let him. He was trying to disprove the naysayers, and was deprived of that opportunity. Fisher based on his injury was actually right this time, but Vince probably looked at it as Fisher's way of keeping him off the field again.
I look at the mistake he made and can't say I wouldn't have done the same thing he did. We all get pissed in the heat of the moment, we are all still human beings with emotions, Vince falls into that more emotional category. I feel he loves football, wants to win a Super Bowl and will make mistakes emotionally for the rest of his life. It's just who he is, he wears his heart on his sleeve. He didn't walk off the field in the middle of a loss after an interception while being booed, but that's how he's being treated. He didn't stomp on a helmetless players face while on the ground, he didn't run anyone off the road. He didn't get wasted and drive his car into another vehicle and kill someone. He isn't fat and a complete waste of space like Jemarcus Russell, he's not Ryan Leaf. What Vince did in my eyes isn't really all that bad. It's not like he's done anything like Pacman and countless others have done, and we are giving him less chances but the same scrutiny. Can't figure that out. I really wanna support him through it. And no I'm not from freaking Texas, not every guy that wants to support Vince has to be from Texas. I'm from the tri state area, which is where N.Y. NJ and PA meet. And a lot of the friends I have from this area that are true football fans feel the same way I do about the situation, which has actually been pretty surprising. I have a lot more to say but need to get the hell off here for a bit lol... Sorry for any typos. Feel free to call me dumb...
89 comments
|
12 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I also
wanted to touch on the fact that I do feel its ok to send a text as an apology. At this point text has pretty much almost replaced phone calls, not exactly on the same level but close… My wife and I talk through text all day long. Yes we even send apologies. It can actually be easier to say how you really feel.
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 6:33 PM CST reply actions
I got into it with my wife one morning but later felt bad about it and texted to saying that I
was sorry and probably shouldn’t have reacted in that manner.
She texted back: Thanks…that means a lot. Luv ya.
So…yeah texts count
This day in age
This is how some people handle things. I think it’s funny that people on Blogs are posting how unprofessional texting is.
by StPrattrick on Nov 24, 2010 7:02 PM CST up reply actions 2 recs
I'm not apologizing through this blog, nor through a text.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:16 PM CST up reply actions
Sorry, I'm not apologizing to *my boss
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:18 PM CST up reply actions
No one is asking you to?
But if one of my employees f-ed something up pretty bad and sent me an email to apologize, I would take it as a start and at least take the attempt as a way of opening lines of communication between us to UNTIL we can talk face to face.
Quit being so critical.
Ah! Right Fisher = Baby Jesus Christ
You know I could use a guy like you Winnie at my business…. You’ll be paid less then min wage and you’ll do all of my responsibilities, but it’s cool because I told you to do it and I am the boss.
Ya
And Vince can do no wrong. Come back when you want to have an educated discussion, and not when you’re here to belittle my intelligence.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:26 PM CST up reply actions
I'm not going to search through the comments again.
I don’t know why I keep replying to you when I always tell myself I won’t.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:34 PM CST up reply actions
But you do.
And I know I never said that he wasn’t wrong. If anything I understood the situation, but he is clearly wrong for what he did and now he’s attempting to straighten it out, which is more then what Fisher is doing.
Why don’t you come back with an intelligence conversation instead of attempting to recall conversations we never had then just making words up on the spot?
Can you provide any evidence whatsoever that Fisher is not attempting to straighten this out?
Neither of us knows what is going on behind the scenes, so don’t assume Fisher has done nothing. We have no idea.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:39 PM CST up reply actions
Then don't assume Vince isn't doing everything he can to straighten this out!
Your contradicting yourself all over the place
But we know what Vince has done to straighten this out.
It was reported.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:42 PM CST up reply actions
Oh God.
I am getting dumber the more I read your comments. I am afraid my unborn children are going to come out a reflection of your stupid if I read any further.
And insults make you look like the better man.
But I have one last question: Were you a VY fan first or a Titan fan first? Just curious, I can’t remember if I asked you already.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:47 PM CST up reply actions
Born in Houston
Been an Oilers fan since I knew what football was. Can’t stand nearly anything that came out of Texas other then The Oilers, Nolan Ryan, Vince Young, and Me.
Maybe that’s why I like(d) VY was much because I thought the whole scenario when they drafted him was perfect, maybe it still could be some day…
Alright.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:55 PM CST up reply actions
and I apologize (see what I did there?!) for calling you dumb
I just still can’t believe this debate is going on, especially when a post as good as this one pretty much lays it out for both parties. It just needs to get figured out, plain and simple.
Frankly, from a third person point of view, both of you were kind of arguing over petty stuff anyway.
by fanoftheunderdogs on Nov 24, 2010 7:58 PM CST up reply actions
When your team hasn't won a game in 4 weeks,
this is what usually happens.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:59 PM CST up reply actions
Yeah, I know.
I’ve spent a lot of time at the 49ers blog doing their Pick’Em games. Total havoc.
Hopefully we get some miracle stability at the QB spot and our defense stops playing hide and seek.
by fanoftheunderdogs on Nov 24, 2010 8:01 PM CST up reply actions
Our Defense is the serious problem that people keep forgetting about since "The Incident"
Seriously,
It
Is
So
Bad
Yeah...
Ever since opposing O-Lines figured out they could actually block, and our secondary started dropping picks, our defense has gone back to stinking.
by fanoftheunderdogs on Nov 24, 2010 8:04 PM CST up reply actions
Oh I agree.
Make no mistake, just because I don’t agree with all of this post does not mean I think it isn’t an outstanding one.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:59 PM CST up reply actions
Wow you're way off bud.
I’m saying that if I screwed up badly, there is NO WAY a text to my boss would solve the issue. Its the same way that I wouldn’t break up with a girl over a text. There are some things that need to be done in person.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:25 PM CST up reply actions
And people need
to agree to disagree that they see the importance of these thing differently. Some people think its ok, and that its a start. Some people don’t
I do think its ok, I don’t think its ok to breakup through text, I see them as 2 completely different things.
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 7:31 PM CST up reply actions
My reply was to the "and Winnie would follow the boss right of a cliff" comment.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:34 PM CST up reply actions
See now in a situation like this, an internet apology is fine.
haha
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:41 PM CST up reply actions
Yeah
but that could be someone else using his cpu to do it lol
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 7:42 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Oh
Well played.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 7:43 PM CST up reply actions
He didn't say that a text to his boss would
solve the problem. He stated that it would help as a starting point.
Apologies over text...
It really depends on the severity of the situation. A spat over something trivial, yeah, a text might be sufficient. Someone guy trying to get forgiveness for cheating on his wife, a text just isn’t going to cut it. He’s gonna have to look her in the eye and show her he truly means he’s sorry. That’s just an example obviously, but the same thought applies. Vince dumped on everyone, especially in Jeff’s eyes, so he has to man up with his apology if he wants it to really mean something to them.
I do sorta feel like Bud
A couple of people got emotional now deal with it. Sometimes you need these big blowups to get past things.
I am not here to convince you otherwise but I thought I'd point out something:
What Vince did in my eyes isn’t really all that bad. It’s not like he’s done anything like Pacman and countless others have done, and we are giving him less chances but the same scrutiny.
There are a few major differences. Pacman’s issues were off the field. They were worse issues from Vince, but it did not affect his teammates. Vince left his teammates out to dry. As for the less chances, I’m not sure I agree with that. Vince had five years to attempt to endear himself to the coaches and players. That’s plenty, in my opinion.
"I didn’t say other people. What do you expect from me, effort-wise?"
by WinnipegTitanFan13 on Nov 24, 2010 6:48 PM CST reply actions
Haynesworth stepped on some guy's head on the field.
Oh, and, a correction on your end…
Vince had five years to attempt to endear himself to thecoaches andplayers.
All the time in the world wouldn’t endear him to Jeff Fisher.
by fanoftheunderdogs on Nov 24, 2010 8:06 PM CST up reply actions
What i find astounding is that everyone on here
knew that the friction between VY and Fish was intense but now everyone is acting so shocked that it blew up.
I think the players like Vince
I don’t think there is anything VY could do to endear Fisher.
How did pacman’s issues off the field that led to him not being able to play on Sundays have no affect on his teammates, that’s the ultimate affect as far as I’m concerned?
Especially less affect than walking out of a meeting. I don’t think Vince had any intent on walking out on teammates hence the “I’m not walking out on them, I’m walking out on you.” As I said he didn’t walk off the field during a game. Of course Fisher would try and get the team to take his side by saying “don’t walk out on your teammates”. It makes it about all of them, not just him. Which really wasn’t the case at all.
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 7:01 PM CST reply actions
Right, I've walked away from plenty of arguments to go cool off.
That’s what my parents always taught me to do, because what is the alternative outcome at that point? God for bid if Vince had taken a swing (And i’m not suggesting he would, but assuming it got past the point of control) Game over. For good. Like Griffen said, people are blowing this way out of proportion.
Wow BBB, this is a Hall Of Fame worthy fanpost
Seriously. The best argument I have heard for Vince since Sunday. Respect.
I will say that we will probably never know everything that happened in that locker room on Sunday, and everything that has been happening behind the scenes. And if Coach Fisher would come clean about everything it would probably shed more light on why he is acting like he is.
But this is good. You definitely made your point.
Official MCM Hater!
Get your Rusty Smith jerseys out!
Yes!
If someone within the actual circle of people involved would just say what the problem is or whats been said, it would clear so much up for the fans out there.
Thanks
I wish we could get a do over for this last Sunday
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 7:54 PM CST up reply actions
Yes, seconded!
That was one of the best posts I have read… a lot of the same had already gone through my mind, and some hadn’t. We are all short on facts and have to read between the lines. That is why none of us is “right.” We only can offer our points of view.
Congratulations for making such a compelling argument!
There are two sides to every story
I’ve been a defender of Vince since he was drafted. But this was going to be his chance to lead this team. When he missed meetings leading up to the Steelers game is when I first started to sour on him. Then looking back, all the signs were there all along. He claims to be this very intense competitor. If that’s true where’s the work ethic?
AJS
I thought those meetings he missed
were deemed ok by Fisher, then used as a reason to bench him 2 days later
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 7:57 PM CST up reply actions
That's the way of NFL coaches.
Didn’t the Redskins’ coach come up with 4 different reasons on why he benched McNabb in the span of 2 days?
by fanoftheunderdogs on Nov 24, 2010 8:09 PM CST up reply actions
No the whole story is
That Vince had been excused from a Wednesday morning meeting to attend an event at the McNair kids school. He came back to the Titans facility several hours later than he told them he would be. Then he also missed a Meeting on Friday which had not been excused.
AJS
No the story is
That Vince had been excused from a Wednesday morning meeting to attend an event at the McNair kids school. He came back to the Titans facility several hours later than he told them he would be. Then he also missed a Meeting on Friday which had not been excused.
AJS
Yeah
I don’t think Fisher is much different than Shanahan… I mean they are like coaching bff’s
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 24, 2010 8:14 PM CST reply actions
This FanPost is Legendary. I salute you.
As far the issue, Why can’t Fisher & Vince just get along? They have set the franchise back 3 years back with this nonsense.
Fisher seriously needs to stop his manipulated ways. And also drop the Ego while he is at it. Vince stop the crying. Does he not understand a lot of People wants him to fail? He is playing into the naysayers hands time and time again.
BBB, Do you think they can make it work? If Not Who should go?
I don't think they can make it work...
I don’t think Fisher wants to.
I don’t know who should go really. I guess the logical answer would be both if feelings weren’t involved. Fisher needs to go 1st and foremost because I think he will be bitter with where Bud has shown his allegiance is. Vince needs to go if the players on the team really feel he quit.
If it comes down to one or the other I would rather see Fisher go. To put it plainly I guess I should say I’m just tired of the way he is, and he’s really never gotten us to where we need to be as a team. I feel this team is going into another tailspin like early last year. Also, a lot of the way I feel on him going instead of VY has to do with the fact I don’t want to start over again at QB. Vince if graded as a player alone has become a good QB, and I feel as a QB alone he can get it done, especially if he has the support of the fans.
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 25, 2010 8:02 PM CST up reply actions
While I know VY can be a bit of a child at times, can anyone on here say Fisher has done the best he can with Vince? I would say if anything he has actually brought out the worst in him.
great line. no one can say fish has handled this in an appropriate, mature way that has best served the team over the past 4 years or the past few weeks or days
While I do agree that this is one stellar post
I think you (all of us actually) are filling in a lot of the relevant details with what fits our own narrative. The Fish/VY saga is 5 years long (excluding off-off-season), and we are all trying to make a case for this or that position based on the tiny miniscule fraction of that time period that we have observables from.
We see the team from a far for 3hrs sunday, get some produced PR tidbits throughout the week, and that’s pretty much it. The rest of time we spend filling in the missing details with whatever we want to think. We’ve extrapolated from our extremely limited set of “relationship samples” to the entire dynamics of a relationship. How can this process possibly produce anything resembling a true picture of what goes on between VY and the Fish?
That’s it for what its worth. Assholing to resume promptly sometime tomorrow. BIRONAS FTW!!!!!!!!!11
Unofficial MCM QB Rating Hater
Unofficial Favorite Person of fanoftheunderdogs
Bironas Fanboy
We can't
possibly produce anything resembling a true picture. I could be completely off base. 10% of my post could be true, and I’m 100% cool with that as I’m provided with 10% of the news and the truth
by Big Bad Bulluck on Nov 25, 2010 9:08 AM CST up reply actions
why Jeff and Vince can't get along:
Jeff Fisher is old school. he played for Ditka, and coached under Buddy Ryan. try to image either of those 2 guys putting up with this crap over and over again.
Old school in the NFL means having zero tolerance for quitters, cry babies, and slackers.
it is not Jeff Fisher’s fault, in any way, shape, or form, that VY is all of the above.
The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.
vince is a quitter, a cry baby, and a slacker
and i bet ditka wouldve gotten the best out of him
how do you know Fisher didn't get the best out of Vince?
why do people still believe he has all this potential after 5 years of proving repeatedly that he is a fragile little quitter who doesn’t work nearly hard enough to be anything but average at his position?
fisher got vince into the playoffs in 2007 despite the fact that he was one of the worst qbs in the league. he also did a masterful job in 2008 of pushing him aside and moving forward with no distractions. how many teams have you ever seen go 13-3 after the starting qb quit on the team at home in week 1? (trick question of course. no other starting QBs that i am aware of have ever quit on their teams in week 1)
fisher has plenty of flaws and i doubt he will survive this season, but i don’t see how he could have done any better than he did turning a fragile, lazy, mental midget into the generally effective QB we saw this season. what Jeff did not do is teach vince how to quit.
at some point the fundamental truth is that the NFL is a man’s game, and children need not apply. vince has no one to blame but himself.
The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.
at some point the fundamental truth is that the NFL is a man’s game, and children need not apply. vince has no one to blame but himself.
agreed, and he coudl easily see himself on the way out. however i dont remember this happening with any other great coach, and there have been lots of immature, not-ready-for-the-nfl, primadonnas. as someone else mentioned moss used to quit on his team plenty (and as much as it pains me to complement him) bellichek never had anything like this
but if you truely believe that fisher has handled this well and has gotten the most of vince then i suppose at some point ppl have to agree to disagree. and believe me if you feel that way youll have many people disagree. 4/4 on ATH yesterday.
this is why vince has never grown up
it’s ALWAYS someone else’s fault.
The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.
also, since you mention randy
if vince really is being victimized, like so many think he is, then do what randy did. stand up, like a man, look into the cameras, tell your side of the story, and then take the consequences and move on to the next team and prove you were right and Fisher was holding you back all along.
don’t run off to your twitter account. don’t call hacks like adam schefter. don’t send text messages. stand up for yourself like an adult.
ps. what does “4/4 on ATH yesterday” mean?
The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.
four out of four on Around the Horn
Straight cash homey
Pro Football South
Get 'em.
by danielreese05 on Nov 25, 2010 1:45 PM CST up reply actions
lol
maybe it was better when i didn’t know what that meant. i would hate to disagree with the worst talking head sports show on TV. oops, stat boy just muted me.
The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.
i put little in the opinions of talking heads
but if they can constantly be used to prop up fisher, they should be able to be used to bring him back down too.
and where did i defend vince or blame someone else? i said his actions are his own. i just also said that many other players are headcases and dont have this drama. you say fisher woudlnt stand for this because of how old school he is – i say a real old school coach wouldve gotten vince in line in 5 years since hes our best option at qb and not brought it to this.
BBB, Nice Job!
I don’t see how you can pick sides overall in this situation.
Thanks for taking the time to make this post!
"What about me and you?" "There is no me and you..." - Marsellus Wallace
by LeftHandedTexan on Nov 25, 2010 10:07 AM CST reply actions
BBB thank you for posting exactly what was going through my head and I couldn't put into words.
Rothbard is right… And so are you since you started off your post this way… A lot of the way we feel is based on our interpretations and assumptions surrounding the situation. And since we are passionate fans, it hits us hard emotionally and we get defensive and what not. I found myself switching back and forth between the sides, one second I am backing VY and one second I am backing Fisher. It’s hard to choose a side in this and it’s unfortunate that we have been put as fans in many situations over the years to argue one side over the other.
There are fans on here that have cemented their sides, that’s for sure, but we all do have the right to discuss our opinions on here. It doesn’t make anyone on here less of a fan if they did choose a side.
Thank you for taking your time and writing this. It makes me feel better seeing this in writing because I couldn’t put it together myself. My brother and I have been debating and arguing over this all week and I never felt I explained my thoughts well. I just sent him this link to read so he knows my side! haha
by Los Blancos Chicca on Nov 25, 2010 10:47 AM CST reply actions
Great post BBB
me, personally, i still could not accept that maybe I have seen the last time VY played for the Titans.
After the Cardinals game last year, I thought this is it! We have found our franchise QB. But I guess not. Let’s see what happens next season.
"We take pride in running the football here". - Eugene Amano, C
great post
perfect way to explain this… couldn’t have said it better.
Don't HAIT. Save the HATTEN for the HAITTERS!
Great Post
For the moment the only I want to add is unless I’m mistaken in OT from one of the camera angles I saw Kerry with his helmet on. May be Vince saw this too and that was the last straw for him.
Interesting post
We may never know everything that really happened behind the scenes. Unfortunately, such an emotional event creates overreaction, and if I may so, many on this blog are reacting like Cleveland fans when Lebron left them. With all due respect, Jimmy’s post trying to minimize VY’s win/loss record is a very poor argument, especially if applied across the board to other QB’s. I understand it helps fans to let go of a player if they attempt to minimize their accomplishments, but like I said, it has sounded a lot like Clevelanders who would have punched someone in the face for saying Kobe > Lebron before last summer and then trashed Lebron’s play after he left with stuff like, “He always choked in the playoffs” and the like.
That said, I believe VY shoulders a great deal of responsibility. I’ve said for a while that Fisher isn’t the right coach for him and has treated him with a stupid double-standard, but Vince is no longer in college. He’s 27 years old. He can’t act like that and expect not to pay the consequences. A lot of us have had to work for bosses we did not like or perhaps misuses our talents, but there were a hundred different ways he could have handled it better. You’re right, VY does not deserve to demonized to the extent many people have done here, but he screwed up badly. The retroactive hate is not justified, but the anger over his behavior certainly is.
by TheElusiveShadow on Nov 27, 2010 7:35 PM CST reply actions 7 recs

by 






























