the only way to read kerry staying the starter from here on out is if fisher is 100% convinced that VY is a bust.

side speculation:
fisher realizes this season is dead in the water and doesn’t want to debut VY’s comeback tour with 2 of the best teams in the AFC. regardless of who we play at QB over the next 2 weeks, the passing defense, as it stands now, is going to lose those games for us on its own. if we start vince twice and get blown out twice, then where do we stand?
maybe he figures he might as well wait for the bye week and then install vince and start working toward the future against lesser opponents and no pressure to win immediately.

He isn’t going to play safety. That other boy from Texas is playing safety and is not doing the job. I don’t know if it’s the players or the coach but the defense is what has cost this team to be 0-4. Is it Cecil or Marcus Robertson that can’t make adjustments or is it the players are still looking at their probowl selections and thinking the are God’s gift and just have to show up? Of course the D line doesn’t apply any pressure on the quarterback and don’t have any sacks to show for the year. There’s a lot of blame to go around and almost all of it belongs on the defense. The offense had to many 3 and outs but to punt and let them score isn’t the offense’s fault. Especially when the get 30 and 40 yard returns.

that is what im thingkin.. wait till bye week and see if were 2-4 or 0-6 .. thru vy in so we can evaluate him before next draft..cause we are wasting time our superbowl window will only stay open for a while

although i just think its more of fish sticking to his word last year that KC would be the starter, that was the only way that he would sign that damn contract, which as i take a look is one year too long. we put so much faith into a QB that really, has not been that great all his career b/c if he was he wouldnt have been a nomad most of his career. i just hope that when VY’s time does come up he can step up, everybody shouldnt expect instant success, even a rusty peyton last year took a while to get back to speed.

but he wouldn’t be as big a part of why they’d be losing as Kerry now is.

sorry, i’m a big joe montana fan.

If Kerry Collins was more productive than last year, you would be 4-0. When the Jaguars took Chris Johnson away, Kerry Collins couldn’t win the game for you. He was a liability.

Not trying to be mean or rubbing it in, God knows I hate that. But to set PK and Jeff Fisher straight, you guys need a new option at QB.

Again, sorry to butt in.

are all out, we have NO CHANCE against those teams. ZERO. we are looking at having 2 rookies and a guy we cut a month ago as our corners. might as well start the process of forgetting those games now.

AH + Schwartz gone, VB still not his old self and maybe never will be, NH not been playing well (although he had some pass defenses finally in that horrible horrible game), offense not sustaining drives to keep them off field, and now injuries to other starters to add icing on the cake. Add it all up and it = defense and season go bye bye.

I didn’t see it coming, though. I’m stunned that the defense has gotten as bad as it has. Everybody had secondary depth concerns coming into this season, but I don’t think anyone expected this mess.

agreed.

Which probably means he ain’t the starter. Bye-bye, VY. As it stands, looks like we got KC for the duration.

succeed in the long run if you don’t throw him back in to start against Indy and NE. He hasn’t really played for over a year. It’s going to take him a few games to get back up to speed – if he can do it at all. This would be true of any QB who has been on the bench for over a year.

thats a good point.. lets see how he does vs these 2 teams.. i mean is kerry really gonna win these 2 games for us?? really? he is 1 interception away from tiying last years mark..

but he’s a biggie now. If we had other options in the secondary I’d be all for them getting a shot, but we don’t. We do, however, have a possible option at QB who could give our D a little more of a break in a best case scenario.

i picked garrard up off waivers just for this week.

I am not giving up. Yesterday’s game was not close, the other 3 were though. The season can be salvaged if things get straight real quick like. I am the eternal optomist.

I don’t think we have good odds of beating Indy or NE with either Collins or Young. In fact, for those two games, Fisher may be right. The odds are slightly better with Collins. Young is not going to come on cold and win those games. Why start him now? What’s the rush?

You can repost your fanpost now, rbarnes.

we’re likely to lose the next two no matter who is QB, so why the big debate. It’s re-arranging deck chairs on the Titanic.