Music City Miracles: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Billy Beane's Challenge: HOW to Add A Hitter? Bar-right-arrows



Grading the 1998 Tennessee Oilers Draft

This is one of the most famous drafts to Tennessee Titans fans because it is the draft where they "passed on Randy Moss to take Kevin Dyson."  I get really tired of hearing that.  The Titans/Oilers were one of 20 teams to pass on Moss.  Also, there is no guarantee that Moss would have been the Randy Moss he was in Minnesota or is in New England if the Titans would have taken him.  With the Jeff Fisher offensive philosophy, it is more likely they would have gotten the Moss from Oakland.  </end rant>

Round 1 Pick #16- Kevin Dyson, WR, Utah

The Dyson grade will in no way reflect the fact that Moss was on the board (see above rant).  This is actually a tough pick to grade.  Dyson is a part of the 2 most famous plays in Tennessee Titan history.  As for his NFL career, it really wasn't that good.  In 6 NFL seasons, 5 with the Oilers/Titans and 1 with the Carolina Panthers, Dyson had 178 catches for 2,325 yards and 18 touchdowns.  His career was cut short because of a knee injury.  Those numbers are decent, but not what you would expect from the #16 pick in the draft. 

Side note:  The only other receiver taken in the 1st round of this draft was Marcus Nash.  Dyson was better than him.

Grade: D

Round 2 Pick #46- Samari Rolle, CB, Florida State

Home run on this one.  Samari started just 1 game his rookie season, but started every game he was healthy for the rest of his 6 seasons with the Titans.  His best season was 2000 when he had 7 picks and made the Pro Bowl.  He was released in the salary cap purge following the 2004 season.

Grade: A+

Round 3 Pick #77- Dainon Sydney, CB, Alabama-Birmingham

Floyd Reese loved to take multiple guys at the same position in drafts.  Sydney was a decent role player for the Titans during the glory years but only started 5 games in his career.  He had 3 picks in each of the 1999 and 2000 seasons, but in his final 3 seasons in the NFL he was only active for 7 games.

Grade: D

Round 4 Pick #107- Joe Salave'a, DT, Arizona

This was a pretty good pick.  Salave'a was never a star in the league, but he was a solid d-line rotation guy for 9 seasons.  That is a good value in the 4th round.

Grade: B

Round 5 Pick #139- Benji Olsen, OG, Washington

Let's see, a 5th round pick that becomes a pillar of your offensive line for 10 years.  Not too shabby!

Grade: A+

Round 6 Pick #168- Lee Wiggins, DB, South Carolina

There is no info available on Wiggins on the internet.  That can't be a good sign.

Grade: F

Round 7 Pick #205- Jimmy Sprotte, LB, Arizona

Sprotte never appeared in a game for the Titans.  He apparently was cut after the 1998 season because he appeared in 9 games in 1999 and 2000 for the Cincinnati Bengals.

Grade: D

Round 7 Pick 229- Kevin Long, C, Florida State

If you live in Nashville and listen to 104.5 in the mornings, you cannot hear the name Kevin Long without thinking about Kevin Long and the Countrywide Home Mortgage team.  This was a great pick.  Long started 35 games in his 4 year career, including 12 games on the 1999 Super Bowl team.

Grade A

This is a much better draft than 1997.  A lot of the guys taken in this draft were crucial to the success this team had when they first became the Titans.

Overall Grade: B

 

Poll
Grade the 1998 Tennessee Oilers Draft
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

  51 votes | Results

0 recs | Comment 5 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

I gave this draft an "A".

I’ll admit the possibility that I’m being a bit easy here, but really, I think this draft represents a Top 15-20% effort of NFL drafting if you were to grade on a normal curve. I say that not just because of the hit rate with the picks but also because, as a core, this was a team that was actually good. Note: guys who couldn’t make this team DID contrbute elsewhere.

So, assuming a normally distributed grading curve:

Round 1 Pick #16- Kevin Dyson, WR, Utah

As 1st round receivers go, Dyson was at least average, and probably a tad better than the statistical “average” of NFL WRs. Hence I’d give this pick a C or maybe a C+

Round 2 Pick #46- Samari Rolle, CB, Florida State

No issue.

Round 3 Pick #77- Dainon Sydney, CB, Alabama-Birmingham

I agree that the philosophy was skewed. That said, I’d say the performance and impact were at least C- compared to other 3rd rnd CBs.

Round 4 Pick #107- Joe Salave’a, DT, Arizona

No issue.

Round 5 Pick #139- Benji Olsen, OG, Washington

I might grade Olson higher than Rolle. On a curve, Olson is an A+ to Rolle’s flat A.

Round 6 Pick #168- Lee Wiggins, DB, South Carolina

No issue.

Round 7 Pick #205- Jimmy Sprotte, LB, Arizona

No issue.

Round 7 Pick 229- Kevin Long, C, Florida State

No issue.

Hmmm… Looking at that makes me think it averages to B+, but I voted “A”.

DannoE

Go read FRIDAY MAD SCIENCE at www.paperbackreader.com
Go Titans!

by DannoE on May 14, 2008 11:58 AM CDT   0 recs

I also gave

the draft an A. Several players made a good impact on the team. Dyson was not a bust at WR. Probably the only one thay have drafted that wasn’t. I would grade him at c+ or B.

I agree with Jimmy that Moss would have not worked in Nashville. Fisher is not a brliever that the Long Ball is a part of football for his teams.

by Tate on May 14, 2008 12:44 PM CDT   0 recs

Little hard on Dyson, I think. I’d give him a C, but overall I agree. The draft gets a B.

by Rustmeister on May 14, 2008 3:01 PM CDT   0 recs

Agreed: Dyson gets a 1 letter grade bump for being crucial in the MCM.

Our best pick-up this off-season has been 'Dinger. Go Titans!

by August West on May 16, 2008 9:29 AM CDT to parent up   0 recs

Rolle

Dyson may not have been an ace, but he was solid enough. The pick of Rolle, however, is beautiful. If this one was redrafted, Rolle would have been a Top 10 guy. Remember when they were comparing him to Deion for a while? It was overkill, but he was a fantastic CB for us.

A wideout, a wideout, my middle linebacker for a wideout!

by Thunder Jones on May 16, 2008 8:01 AM CDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Analysis and in-depth coverage of your Tennessee Titans.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Dd_small
Signing...
Tennesseetitansalt_small
He hates our owner because he's old, bald.
100_3831_small
Just 2 more to go!
Small
Jason Taylor traded to Redskins
Dd_small
OT- Jimmy in New York
Small
I am back !
Titans_action_copy_small
Training Camp
2110887185_c6b161f05a_small
Not to beat a dead horse (more Fowler/PED related intrigue)...
Small
We signed him....
Vinceyoung_small
Manning has infected bursa sac removed from left knee

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Mcnair_small Jimmy

ad

Site Meter